March 20, 2023

 

Dr. Malviya,

I hope this letter finds you well. I never got to say a proper goodbye when you left Ascension Hospital. I want you to know that I truly appreciate all the hard work and dedication that you put into my training. Most of my surgical skills today are directly related to the training that I received from you during my oncology rotations. As I work with more and more residents and attendings you can clearly see the superior skills and confidence of those you trained compared to others who did not. Most recently, I had a patient with a known placenta accreta, and I felt very confident performing a cesarean hysterectomy mostly due to your training. Isolation of the ureters, bladder dissection and back filling the bladder I can honestly say without your training this would not have been possible. Every time I have a difficult case, I use what you taught me to get me through. Post operative clinical management with difficult cases I remember back to what I learned on your rotation. I feel embarrassed that I did not get to thank you in person. I know that you are going through a difficult time currently, but I want to make sure you know that what you taught me does make a positive difference on a daily basis in my practice and for my patients. Your patients were extremely blessed to have such a talented and dedicated physician treating them. I will be forever grateful for what I learned from you.

Joseph J. Prezzato  MD

09/29/2022

My name is Gail Houdek.  I am a registered nurse who has had the privilege to be Dr. Malviya’s nurse for 32.5 years. Dr. Malviya is an excellent physician, surgeon, and gynecologic oncologist. He is a very caring, brilliant man. In working with him, and seeing the outcomes of his surgeries and treatment plans, I can honestly say that I would trust him with my life. When I needed surgery (and my gynecologist had retired), I was thrilled when he offered to do it. He has operated on 2 of my sisters as well; one of which had stage 3 ovarian cancer (diagnosed in 1989), and because of Dr. Malviya, she is alive and well to this day.

A gynecologic oncologist is necessary for the treatment of women’s cancers; specifically, cancers of the cervix, ovary, fallopian tube, uterus/endometrium, vagina, vulva and primary peritoneal. These types of surgeries are beyond the scope of regular gynecologists. With cancer surgery, hysterectomies, which may be called “radical or modified radical”, attempts are made to cut enough healthy tissue around the cancer in order have the cancer “contained”, or with negative margins of resection. This is especially important to make sure that the ureters, or kidney tubes, are protected from tumor involvement. Lymph nodes are also removed in order to stage the cancer. If cancer is advanced, a tumor “debulking” is done; (taking out as much cancer as possible) in order for chemo or radiation to have less tumor to kill. GYN oncologists also manage chemotherapy and radiation therapy.

Dr. Malviya excels in all of the managements of GYN cancers. He explains the procedures, will draw diagrams to help explain the procedures. He will give other options if available. If surgery is not recommended, that chemo or radiation is indicated, he will explain that. If a combination of surgery and chemo or radiation are recommended, he will explain that. Not all of our patients have cancer. Some may have pre-cancerous changes or other problems that can be managed as outpatients. Some patients are referred to him because patients have medical conditions that make them high risk for surgery.  He also operated on patients with benign conditions if it was too difficult for the gynecologist to manage. He can and does successfully manage those patients. He would also go to assist other gynecologists in surgery if they had problems, or if the patients were found to have cancer. Often, he would have to leave an office full of patients to do this. The patients understood for the most part; they may have been one of those patients that he had to leave the office for.

Every patient gets a full exam, including a pelvic and rectal exam with EVERY visit. Follow up is everything. This is necessary because cancers that start in the pelvis, in many cases, will first recur in the pelvis. The rectal exam can also detect any abnormalities in an area called the “cul-de-sac” which is located between the rectum and the vagina, where tumor may recur. Rectal exam also tests for blood in the stool. He always insisted that patients write down their medication list at EVERY visit, so he could review them. If they didn’t comply, he would very firmly tell them how important this list is. They can ask any questions regarding their care, or about any other concerns they have. They will ask his opinion about procedures they have scheduled with other physicians. They know they can tell him anything. They get as much time as they need during office visits. Unfortunately, this creates longer wait times on office days, but most say that he is worth it; he “saved their lives”. When he goes out of town or out of the country, he provides a calling card that HE pays for, so that doctors who are covering for him, or for any of us that have questions can reach him. How many doctors do that? He never forced a patient to have surgery or treatment against their will. If a patient refused surgery or treatment, he respected their decision and was still available for them.

I think that one of the reasons his patients loved him is because they knew that he would not give up on them. They wanted to live; and he always tried his best to help them do that. If nothing more could be done, he would tell them that, and he always followed them for Hospice care. He communicated well with the patients, their families, and their doctors. Patients were sent copies of their office notes, and test results. He would also send this to all of the patient’s doctors.

I was there through it all. I helped him do this for 32.5 years. I am very proud of him, and admire him. I consider him a friend. He even looked out for me when I had gastric surgery. I loved our practice and patients. I am proud that I could assist him. I recommend him to everyone.

“We have worked with Dr. Vinay Malviya for greater than 20 years. Our collective opinion is that Dr. Malviya is a kind, compassionate, dedicated clinician who is always willing to go the extra mile for his patients and his colleagues. Dr. Malviya made himself available to consult, assist and treat our patients with gynecologic cancer. His clinical acumen, intraoperative decision making, and surgical skills are exemplary. He was also willing to participate in the care of patients when called during the surgical procedure for example if a patient believed to have benign disease was found to have cancer during surgery, Dr. Malviya would join the procedure so the patient would not have to come back for a second operation. This tremendously improved the patient’s outcomes, comfort and satisfaction with their care. In addition to his excellent medical care, Dr. Malviya was always empathetic to our patients spending hours counseling them on their disease process and treatments and holding family conferences as needed. Our patients told us they would sometimes encounter long wait times in his office, but they were happy to wait because they knew when it was their turn, they would have his undivided attention for as long as they needed. If we can provide any more information about this fine physician colleague, please reach out to us.”

Jalal Panah MD

Toufic Wehibe MD

Michael Nicholson MD

Aabeen Hagroo D.O.

Leonard Dorey MD

M. Noroozian MD

Staff Obstetrician/Gynecologists

St Joseph Mercy Hospital

Pontiac, MI

“I have been a practicing Ob/Gyn physician for 42 years. I have known Dr. Vinay Malviya for more than 35 years. Over this time, he has become a trusted colleague. I referred all my gynecologic cancer patients to him until his retirement last year. Dr. Malviya is an outstanding physician who made himself available to OB/Gyn physicians in several hospitals both for management of their patients with cancer and those with complex obstetric and benign gynecologic disease. My personal experience with my patients who had gynecologic cancer was that they got seen promptly, diagnosed efficiently and treated appropriately. They were all completely satisfied with his care and provided glowing testimonials of Dr. Malviya’s respectful interactions with them and his expertise in resolving their medical issues. Dr. Malviya believes in managing the whole patient and not just their cancer. As such, the patients felt confident in his ability to treat their complex disease process. It is also well known that Dr. Malviya will take on the care of patients who were considered too complex or old to be treated by other oncologists. Thus, Dr. Malviya often had to deviate from the usual “norms” of clinical practice to tailor make his approach to such patients. Yet, many of these patients are alive and well decades later. His retirement has left a gap in the care of many patients and the practices of several Ob/Gyn Physicians who learned from observing his clinical work. If I can provide additional insights into Dr. Malviya’s work, please feel free to get in touch with me.”

Dr. Usha Ram

Obstetrician and Gynecologist

St Joseph Mercy Hospital Pontiac, MI

“I had the pleasure of working with Dr. Malviya at Ascension Providence Hospital in Southfield from 1998 until 2020. During this time he performed complex Gynecology oncology surgeries on my patients with cancer, patients with extremely difficult pelvises from benign conditions and complicated obstetrical patients. All of my patients that he performed surgery on needed the procedure, had informed consent and had wonderful post-operative recoveries. 

In my over 20-year experience working with Dr. Malviya in the operating room, I found him to be a delicate, precise, methodical and excellent surgeon. In fact, he has received numerous resident teaching awards and accolades from our Ob/Gyn department at Providence. One in particular that I remember was the "Wind Beneath Our Wings" award for his incredible dedication and availability to our department when complex and difficult cases occurred. Dr. Malviya was always willing to help a colleague that needed assistance. 

Lastly, I have seen him show tremendous compassion and empathy with patients and their families in multiple end-of-life conferences. In my opinion, he is a consummate professional Gyn Oncologist and I'm confident that there are many Ob/ Gyn physicians and even more patients whose lives he saved that would agree!!” 

Dr. Sharon Miller

“I have known Dr. Vinay Malviya for many years as a gynecologic oncology surgeon. He always exhibited excellent surgical skills and ability in caring for gynecologic patients. He was always willing to help other doctors doing difficult surgery in the care of their patients.” 

Sincerely,

Anonymous

“To whom it may concern:

Dr. Vinay Kumar Malviya MD FACOG Gynecologic Oncologist. came to be employed at Providence Hospital some 25+ years ago. He was consultant for all my gynecology patients, complicated difficult surgical patients; dense adhesions-endometriosis, obstetric hemorrhage, etc. anytime regardless of clock time. His performance was impeccable as he managed unusual presentations of the Co-morbid patients. He was awesome! My colleagues used his services as I did with the comfort and peace confidently knowing he was up to the task with excellent results. 

Our residency program of currently 20 residents in training benefited immensely from his expertise in training them, consulting, Gyn Tumor board;. his intelligence, knowledge and technical skills were unparalleled. Being in solo practice, the stress of being 24/7 on call and responding to All, gave concerns to those of us who comprehended his passion to eradicate gyn cancer and serve women's health issues within his venue. 

His overwhelming value to women's healthcare, his supportive colleagues, training residents is sorely missed in the tragedy of his loss to our respected profession and dedication to our patients.

Thank you for your kind and humble consideration for these few words of support for a remarkable human being, physician, husband, father, philanthropist.”

-Anonymous Doctor, MD FACOG.

Colleague’s words:

“To my modest, unassuming, amazing friend who was so kind and concerned when I had breast cancer.

It has been an honor and a pleasure to practice medicine with you all these years. Your care and concern for my patients has been extraordinary as are your surgical judgement and skills.

You have seen my patients at 11 PM the day of consultation for large masses as you felt it was the right thing to do. You have fit in patients for urgent surgery (Mondays) so many times and especially if they were Nurses or Doctors because they were ‘one of us.’

Many, many times you were on standby for me on a tough benign case and dropped everything you were doing to help...caesarian hysterectomy included.

So many of my patients are living good lives today because of your care and kindness. I see one almost every day as there are so many you have helped over the years. They revere you! Everyone has nothing but kind words for you and appreciation.

They say there is no one like Dr. Malviya and I agree! Please know that we all LOVE YOU and wish you all the best! You and your family are in my thoughts and prayers.

I enclose a photo of my grand niece and nephew who brighten up my 86 year-old mother’s days. They are here because you removed 20 or 30 fibroids from my niece, K.C. and saved uterus (which no one else would have).

Sincerely, your friend” – Anonymous

“Vinay: I want to thank you for the wonderful doctor that you are and for all the your help over the years. You will be incredibly missed. Please stay in touch and enjoy some rest. I know that will be hard for you. You have had an amazing career in brilliance & empathy. You deserve the best! Good luck” - Anonymous

“Thank you for your help over many years. You have helped me so many times. Good Luck.” – ‘S.P.’ MD

“Thanks for all your help, be well and enjoy retirement.” – ‘H.L.’ MD

“Thank you, Dr. Malviya, for all you taught me and for all your help over the years. Have a restful and happy retirement!” — 'C.D.' DO, 'J.T.' MD, & 'L.C.' DO

Apr 1, 2020

“Hello Dr. Malviya,

Each year on March 31st, I think of you and am grateful for your gift as a surgeon. This year 1am celebrating 15 years as an ovarian cancer survivor, I was at Providence Hospital on 3 S. I was lucky because my ovarian cancer was diagnosed early before there was any major metastases. In 2010 I had a breast lumpectomy with radiation to achieve a second survivorship. We have retired to the _ in Central Florida where we are enjoying the ‘good life’ and remain healthy and happy. I hope you are well and healthy. Forever grateful” — (Retired RN)

“Doctors like you make such a wonderful difference.”

“Dr. Malviya: Thank You for giving DB 26 years of additional life. Even in the final days, mentioning your name gave her a giant smile and I think, some glimmer of hope. God Bless You!” – Anonymous

“Today I/We want to say Thank You for everything and tell you that although you hear this very often, it means so much more!!”

“Dr. Malviya: Aug 1, 2006 Huron Valley Hospital-7/10/2021 Happy 15th Anniversary To Me! There are no words to express how I feel —I am filled with so much gratitude, thankfulness, that you have guided me through 15 years. I know deep in my heart (heart emoji) if you didn’t do my surgery 15 years ago, I wouldn’t be here today. You were born to be the doctor you are today and all of your patients love (heart emoji) you. Dr. Malviya thank you for my life!! Fondly” – Anonymous

“Dr. Vinay, We wish you the best of good fortune and health in your retirement. You will be missed.” – Anonymous

“It was a pleasure dealing with you.” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, although I didn’t get to work with you while working with Metro partners, I would like to thank you for being a teacher during my residency. Good luck in your retirement. I hope to cross paths with you in the future.” – Anonymous

“Thank you for all your hard work over the years. Thank you for helping me out without hesitation. Have fun and rest well. Good Luck.” – Anonymous

“I was very shocked to hear the news of your upcoming retirement. Good luck with your retired life. You have a few decades of sleep to catch up on now (smile emoji). I have always enjoyed taking care of your patients over the last 10+ years, on 3 south and at your office in Southfield, and have learned so much from you and the patients. Best wishes!” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya,

I want to Thank You for being the best doctor in Michigan! I truly believe I had a good outcome with my health thanks to you! You have a wonderful gift of curing your patients! You use intellect, care and I believe common sense so we feel we are really cared for! I thank you from the bottom of my heart!

Love,” – Anonymous

“Miss seeing you. Hope all is going well at your home. Thanks for the coffee!!” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, thank you for your generosity! Best wishes!” — Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, Thank you for everything you have taught me while you were here. We miss you and your complex cases to keep us on our toes.” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, you are truly missed around here. Thank you for everything you have done for my mother and all the patients you have taken care of; of all the surgeons you helped; of all the staff you have worked with. You are truly a blessing. Love” — Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, You’re truly missed by all. We really miss your smooth and efficient techniques. Boy oh boy, do we miss you! You never know how much is a good thing until its gone. I hope they are treating you right at Huron Valley. You are truly a very skilled and dedicated Doctor, who loves his patients. Take care and continue to do this wonderful work of saving lives.” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, missing you so much especially when they need your knowledge and skill. Nice working with you. Good luck and God Bless.” – Anonymous

“Well, Dr. Malviya, the ‘Prov’ OR just isn’t the same without you. I miss working with you! I enjoyed my being in cases, they were rough and tough sometimes, but you helped so many! God’s Blessings.” – Anonymous

“Ma’am, Ma’am, Chief, you'll be missed (heart emoji)” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, I miss you so much. I have learned a lot from you. Hope you are doing well at least less headache for you. Miss seeing you, your silly dance, your ma’am tone...Don’t forget about us” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, I’m going to already miss your happy dance when you scrub in! Thank you for making me a better scrub! Good luck, miss you” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, I hope you’re doing well and good luck in all your future endeavors.” – Anonymous

“Super DOC! I miss you the most! Thank you for making many, many of my Mondays the best. Thank u” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, no one misses you more! My favorite Dr. to work with. Your absence has left a hole no one will ever fill. Mondays will never be the same. Hope your new OR people appreciate your dedication to patient care as much as we did/do.” – Anonymous

“A bittersweet ending” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, miss you!!” – Anonymous

“Dear Dr. Malviya: A Big Thank You From All of Us! Love, Your Providence OR Family” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, You are missed greatly! I wish all the best for you” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, I hope things go well for you! Sure will miss you.” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, I wish you all the well because you’re such a nice person. I will miss you”. – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, we truly miss you especially Malviya Mondays and Thursdays (heart emoji) here at Providence.” – Anonymous

“Dear Dr. Malviya, you will be my favorite surgeon! We miss you terribly... Thank you for all that you do for your patients and for all that you did for us. We love you” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, Miss a lot! Best Wishes!” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, Thank you for all the years of working with you! I will miss you.” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, You have been an outstanding physician, teacher and human being. Always generous and putting your patients’ welfare first. Miss you!!! Always remember that you have many friends here at Providence. Love.” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, Thank you for your thoughtfulness! Many blessings wished for you (hugs).” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, what can I say about my Monday night boyfriend? Malviya Monday but I really miss you and all the cases we did together. I have known and worked with you for many years and have nothing but great admiration and respect for the talented physician and human being that you are. I wish you all the best in the future. God Bless and Stay healthy. Hope our paths will cross in the future.” – Anonymous

“Dr. Malviya, we will miss you.” – Anonymous